liveBook · Manning

Access rights gap

As explained in AI Governance

The access rights gap is the mismatch between legal expectations to provide an account of a person’s data and a trained model’s inability to reliably retrieve that data.

An access rights gap arises when privacy law calls for an account of a person’s data, but a trained model cannot reliably retrieve it. It may return fragments, errors, or nothing—even when personal data shaped its training. section 5.5.2

Separate the model’s core weights from retrievable data stores:

  • A model prompt may reveal a fragment, invent an answer, or produce no answer; it cannot reliably provide a complete list of a person’s data. section 5.5.2
  • A RAG index may point back to documents such as emails, support tickets, chat logs, or HR files. Access workflows can use the underlying documents and explain the role of embeddings, metadata, and logs. section 5.5.2

Jane Smith

Asking “What do you know about Jane Smith?” may yield only a fragment, a plausible invention, or silence. A separate RAG index may instead locate documents associated with her, such as emails. section 5.5.2

How AI Governance covers it

How deep it goes
Distinguishes unreliable recall from model weights and document-linked retrieval, without detailing a complete request procedure.
Examples
Uses a Jane Smith prompt and RAG-held emails, support tickets, chat logs, and HR files.
What you can do after
Evaluate access requests by distinguishing model-generated recollections from retrievable documents and their derivatives.
How it connects
Connects GDPR, data subject access requests, retrieval-augmented generation, embeddings, vector indexes, and model weights.

This explainer was generated by Manning's knowledge graph from the text of AI Governance. The section links point to the parts of the book it draws on.