liveBook · Manning

Arguable statement

As explained in Writing for Developers: Blogs that get read

A statement expressing an opinion or making a claim that a reasonable reader might doubt or disagree with.

An arguable statement expresses an opinion or claim that a reasonable technical reader might doubt or challenge. Treat it as a signal to add evidence rather than as an instruction about what readers should believe. section 5.2.1

Use this quick revision test:

  • Scan for opinions, conclusions, and claims that could prompt “That’s not true” or “How do you know?” section 5.2.1
  • Ask why several times, then follow the claim with experience, code examples, test results, research, or other trusted industry knowledge. section 5.2.1
  • Replace unsupported praise, certainty, and marketing language with specific technical details and qualified conclusions. section 13.5.2

Turn a claim into evidence

Instead of saying “This optimization yielded an impressive performance boost,” share fair before-and-after benchmark results. Instead of calling migration “simple and seamless,” detail the steps and conditions that add complexity.

How Writing for Developers: Blogs that get read covers it

How deep it goes
Defines the pattern, supplies a scan-and-why test, and demonstrates evidence-based rewrites without detailing formal argument theory.
Examples
Uses optimization benchmarks, language comparisons, product experiences, difficulty explanations, migration steps, and code antipatterns.
What it assumes
Assumes a technical draft and a target audience; teaches readers to recognize arguable claims and support them from the ground up.
What you can do after
Diagnose unsupported claims and revise them with concrete experience, experiments, code, benchmarks, or trusted external evidence.
How it connects
Connects arguable statements with facts, technical writing, reader skepticism, evidence, benchmarks, code examples, and trusted industry knowledge.

Related concepts

This explainer was generated by Manning's knowledge graph from the text of Writing for Developers: Blogs that get read. The section links point to the parts of the book it draws on.