liveBook · Manning

Consensual Assessment Technique

As explained in The Creative Programmer

A creativity-assessment method in which qualified experts independently judge the creativity of a product.

The Consensual Assessment Technique evaluates a product’s creativity by inviting qualified experts to judge it. Teresa Amabile coined the term in 1988. section 1.2

What gets judged?

For programmers, the judged product might be a clever algorithm, an invented design pattern, or an entire application. An episode of America’s Got Talent offers a playful analogy: performance judges collectively assess creative work. section 1.2

Keep the method’s scope clear:

  • Assessing the product does not reveal whether its development process was creative; creative processes can produce poor results, while conventional processes can produce creative products. section 1.2

How The Creative Programmer covers it

How deep it goes
Defines expert judgment and distinguishes products from processes, but does not detail a judging protocol or rating procedure.
Examples
Uses algorithms, design patterns, applications, and America’s Got Talent as examples of products receiving creative judgments.
What you can do after
Evaluate/understand creative products while avoiding assumptions that process creativity guarantees creative results.
How it connects
Connects creativity assessment with creative products, creative processes, algorithms, design patterns, and applications.

Related concepts

This explainer was generated by Manning's knowledge graph from the text of The Creative Programmer. The section links point to the parts of the book it draws on.