Debate-style judging makes an evaluator construct the strongest case for each alternative before weighing those cases and issuing a verdict. This delays premature preference and reduces the risk of rationalizing an initial impression. section 10.3.3
A pairwise judging flow uses four explicit stages:
- Argue for Response A using specific evidence and the stated criteria. section 10.3.3
- Argue for Response B with the same requirement for evidence. section 10.3.3
- Weigh both arguments, testing which case survives scrutiny and which relies on weaker or unsupported claims. section 10.3.3
- Render a verdict only after both cases have been constructed. section 10.3.3
Self-debate for pairwise comparison
One model can play both advocate roles within a single invocation, comparing two responses against criteria such as accuracy, relevance, and clarity. The process restructures one reasoning trace rather than creating independent judges. section 10.3.3
