liveBook · Manning

Evaluation design

As explained in AI Model Evaluation

An evaluation design is a deliberate specification of the data, metrics, judgments, comparisons, scenarios, and decision rules used to assess a model or AI system.

Evaluation design specifies how to assess a model or AI system against an objective. It connects input data to results by defining what to measure, which scenarios to test, how to sample, and how much confidence to place in the findings. The design should support a decision, not just produce a high metric. section 2.2 section 2.2.2

A practical offline evaluation design makes these choices explicit:

  • Inputs: Select historical interactions, ground-truth labels, and contextual metadata relevant to the objective. section 2.2
  • Measures and scenarios: Define metrics, evaluation granularity, and conditions such as cold-start users, ambiguous prompts, or failed tool calls. section 2.2 section 2.2.2
  • Sampling and confidence: Specify how cases are sampled and confidence is estimated. section 2.2
  • Decision rules: Set what improvement is meaningful, how much guardrail degradation is acceptable, and which failures block launch. section 2.2.2
  • Reproducibility: Document and version datasets, models, code, metric definitions, and other relevant artifacts, such as prompts, rubrics, judge models, and evaluation configuration. section 2.2.2
Table 2.4 Offline Evaluation Input/Design/Output Summary
Element
Description
Example
Input
The data fed into the evaluation process. This forms the foundation of the offline evaluation.
- User interaction logs (JSON, Parquet)
- Ground truth labels (binary, multi-class)
- Metadata (device_type, location)
Design
The structure of the evaluation: how it's run, what it tests, and how results are calculated.
- Metric definitions such as Precision@10 or NDCG@5
- Simulation setup such as cold-start users or missing feature tests
- Evaluation granularity such as per-session or per-user
Output
The results of the evaluation: quantitative and diagnostic signals about model behavior.
- Performance metrics
- Diagnostic insights
- Visual reports or dashboards

Use the input/design/output summary to connect concrete data formats, design choices, and diagnostic results. section 2.2

Movie recommendations

For a recommendation model, use interaction logs, labels, and user metadata as inputs. Define Precision@10 and test cold-start users, specifying whether results are calculated per user or per session. Interpret the resulting performance and diagnostic signals against the product objective before deciding whether to iterate or proceed to online testing. section 2.2 section 2.2.2

Offline results can mislead if evaluation data leaks into training, prompts, features, or labels, or if historical metrics do not reflect the product goal. Use careful splits, time-aware design, and versioned artifacts. An online A/B test compares a treatment with a control to measure what happens with real users; if results disagree with offline findings, inspect segments, logs, inputs, exposure, and the offline design before settling on a cause. section 2.5 section 6.5.5 section 6.1

When comparing multiple online variants, give each a clear hypothesis and plan for interpreting results. More variants require more traffic or time and increase the risk of false positives; corrections such as Bonferroni or false discovery rate can account for multiple comparisons. section 6.5.1

How AI Model Evaluation covers it

How deep it goes
Details inputs, metrics, scenarios, sampling, confidence, decision rules, reproducibility, and checks for offline-online disagreement.
Examples
Uses recommendation interaction logs, Precision@10, cold-start users, and variants emphasizing recency, user affinity, or diversity.
What you can do after
Evaluate and understand model readiness by specifying tests and decision rules, then interpreting offline results alongside online evidence.
How it connects
Connects offline evaluation with A/B testing, data leakage, robustness, guardrail metrics, and multiple comparisons.

Related concepts

This explainer was generated by Manning's knowledge graph from the text of AI Model Evaluation. The section links point to the parts of the book it draws on.