A grounded answer supports its claims with retrieved evidence instead of filling gaps with plausible-sounding guesses. When evidence is missing or weak, the safer response is to acknowledge uncertainty, defer, or connect the user with a human specialist. section 6.2.2
When the evidence does not answer the question
A user asks whether a booster could worsen dysphagia associated with achalasia. If the retrieved resources do not clearly answer this, a responsible system says it could not find a clear answer and offers connection to a specialist. This avoids presenting an unsupported medical claim as fact. section 6.2.2
Evaluate a response by checking whether it:
- Uses retrieved passages that support its claims. section 6.2.2
- Deflects or returns an explicit fallback when retrieval finds nothing. section 6.2.2
- Escalates to a human when generated content has poor overlap with the evidence. section 6.2.2
Table 6.1 A comparison of answers for intents and RAG
|
Interaction with an intent-based bot
|
Interaction with a RAG-integrated bot
|
|---|---|
User: What are the current COVID-19 guidelines for restaurants in New York?
PharmaBot: Current COVID-19 guidelines for restaurant dining include limited indoor capacity, mask requirements for staff and patrons when not seated, and enhanced cleaning protocols. Please check local regulations for the most up-to-date information.
|
User: What are the current COVID-19 guidelines for restaurants in New York?
PharmaBot: COVID-19 remains a significant concern for New Yorkers. Make sure you are up to date on the updated COVID-19 vaccines for the 2023-2024 season that offer protection against emerging variants and enhance overall immunity. Masks continue to be effective tools in mitigating the spread of COVID-19 and other respiratory viruses, reducing the transmission of droplets during various activities. To minimize the risk of contracting COVID-19, individuals are advised to wear masks in crowded indoor public settings.
Source: NYC Health
|
Compare how intent-based and retrieval-augmented responses handle the same changing-information question. section 6.2.2
