liveBook · Manning

Majority illusion

As explained in Hidden Influences

A phenomenon in which a belief appears more widely accepted through a person's network than it is in the population overall.

A belief can seem popular simply because the people expressing it are prominent in your network. The majority illusion occurs when a belief appears more widely accepted than it is in the population overall. section 8.1.1

Red and white roses

On a five-user flower platform, three people prefer red roses and two prefer white roses. Red is the majority preference, but if the white-rose advocates have more followers, users may see their preference more often and mistake it for the majority view. section 8.1.1

People cannot take in everything happening across a platform. Instead, their local view—what they see from the people they follow—can shape their beliefs. When well-connected people hold a minority opinion, that local view can differ from the global picture. section 8.1.1

Figure 8.1 An example of how the shape of the network, i.e., its connections, influences the flow of information. In diagram A, the circle nodes are better connected than the square ones. Because of that, the square nodes would receive more information from the circular ones, giving the impression that their opinion is the majority. In contrast, a different network shape, shown on the right, can lead to a very different spread of information where the square nodes receive the majority of their information from other square nodes.

Compare how two network shapes change which opinions users encounter most often. section 8.1.1

How Hidden Influences covers it

How deep it goes
Uses a small network to explain the gap between local exposure and the global majority.
Examples
Illustrates the illusion with five users choosing red or white roses and diagrams of differently connected networks.
What you can do after
Enables readers to evaluate whether their network view reflects the wider population.
How it connects
Connects social networks, group belonging, and recommender systems.

This explainer was generated by Manning's knowledge graph from the text of Hidden Influences. The section links point to the parts of the book it draws on.