liveBook · Manning

Misalignment

As explained in The AI Pocket Book

A mismatch between the task a model was trained to optimize and the task it is later used for.

Misalignment is the gap between what a model is trained to optimize and what people later ask it to do. Predicting a plausible next token can produce fluent text without producing factual or useful information. section 2.10

A plausible but invented answer

When ChatGPT invented book titles, the response looked like a likely continuation of the prompt. That may have been a strong next-token prediction, even though the titles were false. Manual preference data can narrow this gap by encouraging helpful and safe behavior, but it does not remove it. section 2.10

The same problem appears in predictive modeling. A model trained to predict whether a product sells is not automatically a model of how changing its price affects sales. If historical prices barely vary, it may rely on color or star rating instead. Testing an unseen price can therefore generate a confident fiction with no corresponding training loss. section 2.11

Adding factual documents through retrieval can make responses more convincing, but it does not by itself change the model’s basic objective. The practical takeaway is simple: judge a model against the task you intend to use, not only the metric used during training. section 2.10 section 2.11

How The AI Pocket Book covers it

How deep it goes
Traces objective mismatch through next-token prediction, missing price variation, proxy features, and absent training penalties.
Examples
Uses invented book titles and hypothetical T-shirt prices to show plausible text and confident business predictions failing differently.
What it assumes
Assumes basic familiarity with model training, prediction, prompts, and business metrics while illustrating the mismatch through concrete cases.
What you can do after
Evaluate model outputs against the intended task instead of treating training performance as evidence of factuality or causal validity.
How it connects
Connects hallucinations, language modeling, user instruction following, retrieval-augmented generation, and causal analysis.

Also explained in

Compare how 3 books explain misalignment →

Related concepts

This explainer was generated by Manning's knowledge graph from the text of The AI Pocket Book. The section links point to the parts of the book it draws on.