liveBook · Manning

Polarization

As explained in Hidden Influences

A social or political condition in which opinions, groups, or identities become increasingly divided into opposing extremes.

Imagine two people following the same news event but seeing very different feeds. Each may encounter sources they trust and dismiss those associated with the other side. Polarization is the growing division of opinions or groups into opposing extremes; online feeds can deepen a division that already exists. section 7.5.1 section 7.0

Recommender systems designed to optimize engagement respond to previous actions rather than journalistic ethics. In news feeds, this can reinforce preferences for agreeable sources and amplify extreme voices. Social media and recommender systems accelerated an existing trend toward distrust and polarization; they did not create it on their own. section 7.5.1

Playing both sides

Accounts linked to the Russian Internet Research Agency appeared in both pro- and anti-Black Lives Matter clusters. By pushing emotional, extreme positions on both sides, they could make a complex issue seem like a binary choice and make the discussion appear more polarized than it might have been. section 10.2.4

The effects can reach beyond people who use a platform: changes to public debate affect the wider public. But separating the influence of recommender systems from the broader growth of internet use is difficult, so simple claims about a single cause deserve scrutiny. section 7.0

Older news media also had commercial incentives and were not necessarily neutral or ideal. The key distinction is not that earlier media were free of bias, but that an engagement-driven feed has no mandate to inform the public. section 7.5.1

How Hidden Influences covers it

How deep it goes
Explains reinforcing mechanisms and their social consequences, while acknowledging the difficulty of isolating recommender effects from broader internet use.
Examples
Uses partisan news preferences and Russian-linked accounts active on both sides of Black Lives Matter discussions.
What you can do after
Evaluate and understand claims about online polarization by questioning simple causes and scrutinizing extreme content.
How it connects
Connects polarization to recommender systems, engagement optimization, news media, propaganda, and in-group and out-group dynamics.

Related concepts

This explainer was generated by Manning's knowledge graph from the text of Hidden Influences. The section links point to the parts of the book it draws on.