Table extraction recovers structured rows and columns from PDFs for analysis. The practical choice depends on file volume, automation needs, cost, privacy, and setup effort. section 5.4.2
A pragmatic extraction workflow is:
- Define the tables and fields needed before choosing a method. section 5.4.2
- Compare manual copying, dedicated extraction tools, and capabilities in the existing toolkit. section 5.4.2
- Use pdfplumber to find page tables, convert extracted lists into pandas DataFrames, and reshape columns or rows as needed. section 5.4.2
- Combine yearly tables, verify expected row counts, and export the resulting data to CSV. section 5.4.2
Extracting tables from selected pages
Open a PDF with pdfplumber, call find_tables() for each selected page, convert each result to a DataFrame using the first row as headers, and collect the tables. section 5.4.2
Table 5.1 Comparing PDF extraction techniques
|
Option
|
Pros
|
Cons
|
|---|---|---|
|
Manually copying data from PDFs into Excel
|
• Quick for a small amount of data
|
• Cannot be automated
• Does not scale to more data
|
|
Dedicated PDF extraction tool, either web or desktop based
|
• Likely to be accurate
• Web-based tool requires no installation
|
• May not be free
• Privacy concerns if uploading files to the web
• Hard to automate
• May not scale to multiple files
|
|
Finding PDF capabilities in our current tool
|
• Allows automation and scales to many files
• No need to leave/change our preferred tools
|
• Current toolkit may not have such capabilities
• If there are few files and a one-off task, it might be quicker to extract data manually.
|
Compare speed, accuracy, automation, scalability, installation, cost, and privacy across extraction approaches. section 5.4.2
