liveBook · Manning

Critical dialogue

As explained in Claude at Work

Critical dialogue is an interaction technique that actively questions and evaluates an AI system's suggestions rather than accepting them uncritically.

Critical dialogue means actively steering an AI conversation rather than accepting each suggestion as the next step. Bring your experience and judgment: correct mistakes, clarify the goal, and change direction when a response is plausible but not quite what you need. section 1.0 section 1.3

Review both the plan and the output. Before generation, examine the proposed approach and establish a shared understanding of the task. Treat the first output as a draft: gauge its overall correctness, iterate to close gaps, and review more closely as it improves. section 2.7

At each turn, choose how to proceed:

  • Accept and extend a useful response when it advances the goal. section 2.7
  • Block or redirect a thread when the response has gaps or follows the wrong premise. Push back with evidence when it is wrong. section 2.7 section 2.9
  • Start a fresh conversation with a better opening prompt if the current one has gone sideways. section 2.9

Review a plan before generation

For a software task, try: “Before producing the implementation, explain your proposed approach and how it meets this goal and these constraints: [details].” Review the plan, correct or redirect it, and only then ask for the output. Treat that output as a first draft and iterate before a closer review. section 2.7 section 2.9

How Claude at Work covers it

How deep it goes
Explains how to review plans and drafts, accept or block a direction, and restart a confused conversation.
Examples
Uses an improvisation analogy and a story about repeatedly returning a report to illustrate steering and review.
What it assumes
Assumes the user brings relevant experience and judgment to guide and correct the assistant.
What you can do after
Practice steering a conversation, reviewing output, and changing direction or starting fresh when needed.
How it connects
Connects critical dialogue to prompt structure, iteration, and evidence-based evaluation.

Related concepts

This explainer was generated by Manning's knowledge graph from the text of Claude at Work. The section links point to the parts of the book it draws on.