Critical dialogue means actively steering an AI conversation rather than accepting each suggestion as the next step. Bring your experience and judgment: correct mistakes, clarify the goal, and change direction when a response is plausible but not quite what you need. section 1.0 section 1.3
Review both the plan and the output. Before generation, examine the proposed approach and establish a shared understanding of the task. Treat the first output as a draft: gauge its overall correctness, iterate to close gaps, and review more closely as it improves. section 2.7
At each turn, choose how to proceed:
- Accept and extend a useful response when it advances the goal. section 2.7
- Block or redirect a thread when the response has gaps or follows the wrong premise. Push back with evidence when it is wrong. section 2.7 section 2.9
- Start a fresh conversation with a better opening prompt if the current one has gone sideways. section 2.9
Review a plan before generation
For a software task, try: “Before producing the implementation, explain your proposed approach and how it meets this goal and these constraints: [details].” Review the plan, correct or redirect it, and only then ask for the output. Treat that output as a first draft and iterate before a closer review. section 2.7 section 2.9
