A docking score is a numerical estimate of how favorably a small molecule, or ligand, binds to a target such as a protein. Molecular docking explores possible binding poses and scores them to rank candidates for further study. The score is an approximation, not a measurement of actual binding affinity. section 9.0 section 9.1.5
In a Vina docking result, the affinity column gives the score for each pose in kcal/mol-like units. Lower scores indicate more favorable poses. Other columns describe interaction energy and internal strain; they are useful diagnostics, but poses are ranked by affinity alone. section 9.1.5
Comparing poses
A nine-pose result ranks pose 0 first at −9.246, followed by pose 1 at −8.543. The difference is about 0.703 kcal/mol. A better-ranked pose is a candidate for inspection, not proof that the ligand binds as predicted. section 9.1.5
# Output of print(results) —9 poses, sorted best to worst: affinity inter intra torsions intra_best_post 0 -9.246 -13.571 -1.112 4.324 -1.112 1 -8.543 -11.782 -1.868 3.995 -1.112 2 -8.531 -12.003 -1.629 3.990 -1.112 3 -8.480 -11.860 -1.698 3.966 -1.112 4 -8.353 -12.081 -1.291 3.907 -1.112 5 -8.298 -11.132 -2.159 3.881 -1.112 6 -8.084 -11.139 -1.837 3.781 -1.112 7 -7.958 -11.056 -1.736 3.722 -1.112 8 -7.868 -10.555 -2.104 3.680 -1.112
Compare the affinity ranking with the diagnostic energy columns across all nine poses. section 9.1.5
Check promising scores before drawing conclusions:
- Inspect top poses for favorable contacts, steric clashes, and realistic conformations. section 9.1.5
- Compare with the original ligand pose as a control, or rescore top poses with other scoring functions and look for agreement. section 9.1.5
- Use molecular dynamics to assess pose stability or experiments to determine actual binding affinity. Published score thresholds are not comprehensive or precise. section 9.1.5
For very large libraries, docking every molecule can be expensive. Progressive docking uses scores from an initially docked subset to train a surrogate model that predicts score proxies for other molecules. An active learning loop selects another batch, obtains benchmark scores from a docking oracle, and retrains the model within a computational budget. section 9.0 section 9.2.7
Tracking screening progress
In a 4AG8 dataset experiment, a proxy oracle looks up previously computed scores rather than running docking for each test. After 7,500 molecules had been selected, the run had found 73 of the dataset’s top 100 molecules by docking score. This measures recovery against that reference ranking, not experimental binding success. section 9.2.6 section 9.2.7
# Output of results_df.head(10).to_string() — per-iteration progress: iteration total_molecules top_molecules_found best_score time 0 1 5250 13 -20.57 2.60 1 2 5500 19 -20.57 4.86 2 3 5750 32 -20.66 1.84 3 4 6000 41 -20.66 1.22 4 5 6250 51 -20.66 1.23 5 6 6500 58 -20.66 1.32 6 7 6750 61 -20.66 1.89 7 8 7000 67 -20.66 1.78 8 9 7250 71 -20.66 1.47 9 10 7500 73 -20.66 1.49
See how the best score and number of top-reference molecules found change over ten iterations. section 9.2.7
