liveBook · Manning

Engagement-based recommender system

As explained in Hidden Influences

A recommendation approach that selects or ranks content according to predicted or measured user engagement.

A social media feed can rank content according to user engagement. The system’s recommendations shape what people see; their interactions then provide validation and training data for later recommendations. section 8.0

This is a socio-technical loop, not just an algorithmic one: human responses, system behavior, and the society and historical period in which the technology emerges all help explain its effects. section 8.0

Engagement-based recommendations are considered a major cause of negative externalities on social media. Changing the engagement model may conflict with a platform’s business model, so safety proposals can focus on making existing practices less harmful instead. Such changes may reduce harm without addressing its underlying source; overmoderation also risks limiting audiences for historically excluded communities. section 9.3

The limits of harm reduction

The tobacco analogy distinguishes reducing harm from addressing its source: filters may make smoking less damaging, but they do not stop cigarette production. Likewise, making a harmful platform less biased may leave the incentives driving harm in place. section 9.3

How Hidden Influences covers it

How deep it goes
Explains feedback and societal context, but does not detail algorithms or implementation.
Examples
Uses social media recommendations and a tobacco-filter analogy to illustrate platform incentives and harm reduction.
What you can do after
Evaluate safety proposals against the engagement incentives and business models they may challenge.
How it connects
Connects recommender systems with feedback loops, platform business models, and content moderation.

Related concepts

This explainer was generated by Manning's knowledge graph from the text of Hidden Influences. The section links point to the parts of the book it draws on.