liveBook · Manning

Peer review

Peer review is the assessment of work by knowledgeable colleagues or independent experts to evaluate its quality, correctness, validity, or reasoning and provide feedback.

How 2 Manning books explain it

Writing for Developers: Blogs that get read

The evaluation of a work by one or more knowledgeable colleagues who provide feedback on its quality, completeness, or correctness.

How it is used
Uses colleague feedback to uncover major gaps and omissions in engineering blog drafts.
How deep it goes
Defines the purpose and practical limits of review, but defers detailed review-process navigation.
Examples
Uses omissions involving migration, process impact, original problems, security, and generative-AI feedback.
What you can do after
Diagnose major omissions by soliciting focused colleague feedback and evaluating AI-generated concerns.

Read how Writing for Developers: Blogs that get read explains peer review →

Investing for Programmers

Peer review is the evaluation of an analysis or argument by other knowledgeable people to identify weaknesses and improve its reasoning.

How it is used
Uses informed challenge to refine investment theses and prevent rushed, assumption-driven decisions.
How deep it goes
Provides a practical review loop involving explanation, questioning, documentation, and retrospectives, but not a formal review framework.
Examples
Uses a friend challenging a proposed share purchase, documented investment decisions, and the Buffett–Munger advisory relationship.
What you can do after
Practice/perform peer review by explaining a thesis, inviting challenge, recording expectations, and revisiting the decision.

Read how Investing for Programmers explains peer review →

Also covered in

What to know first

Related concepts

Questions about peer review

What is peer review?

Peer review is the assessment of work by knowledgeable colleagues or independent experts to evaluate its quality, correctness, validity, or reasoning and provide feedback.

Which Manning books explain peer review?

Writing for Developers: Blogs that get read and Investing for Programmers.

What should I know before learning peer review?

Manning books that teach peer review usually introduce production first.

What is the difference between peer review and arXiv?

Peer review is the assessment of work by knowledgeable colleagues or independent experts to evaluate its quality, correctness, validity, or reasoning and provide feedback. arXiv is an open-access repository and preprint server for scholarly research papers, particularly in science, mathematics, and computer science.

What kinds of peer review are there?

Kinds of peer review include code review.

What is peer review part of?

Peer review is part of checks and balances. A control pattern in which independent roles or viewpoints constrain one another to reduce errors and excessive bias.

These guides are generated from the text of Manning books by Manning's knowledge graph and link to the sections they draw on. The full books are available on liveBook and at manning.com.