liveBook · Manning

Second-order effect

As explained in Hidden Influences

An unintended consequence that arises indirectly from a technology’s initial effects on behavior or conditions.

A second-order effect is an unintended consequence that appears indirectly after technology changes behavior or surrounding conditions. Streaming may lead people to visit cinemas less often, reducing the diversity of films those theaters offer. section 7.0

These effects can extend beyond direct users. As social media becomes a gateway to news, purchasing, eating, and political opinions, its influence can affect elections, culture, news media, and people who never use the platforms. section 7.0

Common patterns include:

  • Behavioral change: people spend more time and money streaming films. section 7.0
  • Institutional or market change: fewer cinema visits may contribute to smaller theaters closing or offering less variety. section 7.0
  • Social spillover: polarization, weakened news media, and changed self-understanding affect users and non-users alike. section 7.0

How Hidden Influences covers it

How deep it goes
Defines indirect unintended consequences and illustrates them through streaming, cinemas, social media, and non-user spillovers.
Examples
Uses streaming, declining cinema variety, social-media news exposure, voting choices, polarization, and effects on non-users.
What it assumes
Assumes only familiarity with everyday technology use and distinguishes direct online behavior from indirect offline consequences.
What you can do after
Evaluate how a technology’s direct behavioral effects may produce wider, unintended consequences for users and society.
How it connects
Connects second-order effects with social media, online platforms, political influence, news media, polarization, and market change.

Related concepts

This explainer was generated by Manning's knowledge graph from the text of Hidden Influences. The section links point to the parts of the book it draws on.