A specification format defines how requirements and decisions are recorded. Its job is to retain enough intent to guide implementation: if a conversation settles validation behavior but the specification records only a vague sentence, the format has lost important distinctions. section 3.2.2 section 3.6.1
Listing 3.2 Capturing malformed URL validation in Gherkin format
Feature: Shorten URL
Scenario: Reject malformed URL
Given the user submits a malformed URL
When the shorten URL request is processed
Then the service returns the expected validation status
And the response explains the validation failure
And no short link is storedA malformed-URL scenario makes the expected status, explanatory response, and absence of stored data explicit—details a thin requirement could omit. section 3.2.2
Assess a format by the choices it makes and the tradeoffs they create:
- Requirement structure ranges from natural-language stories and acceptance criteria to constrained formats such as EARS and Gherkin, or machine-parseable formats. More structure can expose missing behavior and reduce interpretation, while machine-parseable syntax takes effort to learn. section 3.6.1
- Also consider where specifications live, how finely they are divided, and how they are organized. These choices affect verifiability, authorship, review, and the ability to understand the current system. section 3.6.1
- Strengthen the format when intent was discussed but recorded too loosely. Route other gaps to the workflow stage that allowed them: dialogue, construction constraints, or verification. section 3.2.2 section 3.2.5
