liveBook · Manning

Prototype

As explained in Decision Engineering

A preliminary version of a product or system created to test ideas before fuller development.

A prototype is a working, hands-on implementation for evaluating a product or technology. It reveals qualities that feature lists may miss, including how an editing experience feels and how quickly a team can make a working change. section 4.2.3

Make the prototype answer a decision, rather than treating a successful run as proof that a technology is suitable.

  • Decide in advance what the prototype should demonstrate, then build it to stress the specific concerns being evaluated. section 4.2.3
  • A simple greenfield “Hello world” may prove little if it exercises none of the relevant concerns. section 4.2.3
  • Rapid prototyping can make it practical to test multiple candidates earlier; rebuilding the same use case with another technology supports a more comparable evaluation. section 4.2.3 section 1.3.2

Compare the experience

For a visual editor, spend time using the actual product: direct experience can reveal more about its feel and learning curve than vendor materials or a feature list. section 4.2.3

How Decision Engineering covers it

How deep it goes
Plan what a prototype must demonstrate and stress relevant concerns; avoid treating a basic working example as sufficient evidence.
Examples
Use a visual editor hands-on or rebuild the same prototype with different technologies to compare experience and learning curve.
What it assumes
Identify the concerns a prototype should test; no specific technical background is stated as a prerequisite.
What you can do after
Evaluate technologies by testing relevant assumptions with working implementations and comparing candidates on the same use case.
How it connects
Connects prototypes with proof of concept, technology evaluation, requirements, and AI-assisted development.

Related concepts

This explainer was generated by Manning's knowledge graph from the text of Decision Engineering. The section links point to the parts of the book it draws on.