liveBook · Manning

Commodity

As explained in Architecture Modernization: Socio-technical alignment of software, strategy, and structure

The commodity stage is the mature Wardley evolution stage in which a component is standardized, widely available, and comparatively predictable.

Commodity is the mature stage of evolution on a Wardley Map. A commodity component is widespread, standardized, and commonly understood in use. Customers expect it, while competitors have similar versions. It is usually a cost of doing business rather than a source of differentiation; stability and efficiency matter more than novelty. section 5.2 section 5.4.1

To assess a component, ask how widely it is used and how much remains to learn about using it. A widespread capability with familiar uses points toward commodity. An industry’s publications can offer another clue: at this stage, they focus on use rather than construction or emerging features. These are prompts for discussion, not a precise classification test; placement calls for industry knowledge and multiple perspectives. section 5.3.1

What commodity can look like

In online food delivery, menus are widespread and familiar, making them commodity-like. A cloud platform can also sit at the commodity stage when it resembles competitors’ platforms and is largely delegated to a provider. Neither example implies that every component in the same business belongs there: ordering may still offer some scope for differentiation. section 5.3.1 section 5.2

Table 5.1 The three evolution characteristics (view table figure)

  

Genesis

Custom built

Product

Commodity

Ubiquity

Rare

Slowly increasing consumption

Rapidly increasing consumption

Widespread and stabilizing

Certainty

Poorly understood

Rapid increases in learning

Rapid increases in use/
fit for purpose

Commonly understood (in terms of use)

Publication types

Normally describe the wonder of the thing

Build/
construct/
awareness and learning

Maintenance/
operations/
installation/ features

Focused on use

Compare ubiquity, certainty, and publication types across all four evolution stages before deciding where a component belongs. section 5.3.1

Commodity status also changes investment decisions. If a capability is likely to become available off the shelf soon, major investment in a bespoke version may bring little lasting advantage. A company with an in-house CRM wanted to move to a cheaper-to-operate service, but tight coupling to bespoke capabilities made the move expensive. When mapping likely changes, ask both what may become a commodity and what architectural dependencies could make a later build-versus-buy decision costly. section 5.4.5

Losing differentiation in one component need not end innovation elsewhere. As components become widespread, they can enable new capabilities: commodity electricity supported new products, while evolving online payments helped more businesses operate online. Ask what becomes possible as a component matures, as well as what advantage it ceases to provide. section 5.4.2

How Architecture Modernization: Socio-technical alignment of software, strategy, and structure covers it

How deep it goes
Defines commodity through assessment characteristics and industrialized properties, while leaving exact placement to judgment rather than a precise test.
Examples
Illustrates commodity assessment with food-delivery menus and a coupled in-house CRM facing migration to Salesforce.
What it assumes
Introduces the four evolution stages and assessment characteristics while relying on industry expertise to judge component placement.
What you can do after
Practice/perform map reviews to flag soon-commoditized investments and dependencies that could make later service migrations costly.
How it connects
Links commodity to Wardley Mapping, evolution stages, competitive advantage, climatic change, and build-versus-buy decisions.

Related concepts

This explainer was generated by Manning's knowledge graph from the text of Architecture Modernization: Socio-technical alignment of software, strategy, and structure. The section links point to the parts of the book it draws on.