liveBook · Manning

Determinism

As explained in Causal AI

Determinism is the philosophical view that a system's complete state and governing laws uniquely determine its future state.

Determinism treats a data-generating process as fixed by its complete causes: given the same initial conditions and governing laws, the outcome is certain. Probability can still describe a modeler’s uncertainty about those causes rather than randomness in the process itself. section 2.4 section 2.5

A die roll may appear random because its physical causes are unknown; with complete knowledge of its initial conditions and mechanics, its outcome would be predictable. Some systems may contain inherently stochastic elements, but this deterministic modeling perspective applies to most systems of interest. section 2.4.1 section 2.4.1

Listing 6.2 CGM rewritten as an SCM
from pyro.distributions import Normal
from pyro import sample

def scm_model():
    n_x = sample("n_x", Normal(0., 2.3))    #1
    n_y = sample("n_y", Normal(0., 3.3))   #1
    x = 47. + n_x     #2
    y = 25. + 3.*x + n_y    #2
    return x, y    #3

This structural causal model separates random exogenous inputs from deterministic assignments: the inputs vary, while the functions set the values of X and Y. section 6.1.2

How Causal AI covers it

How deep it goes
Defines deterministic generation through fixed causes and initial conditions, while acknowledging systems that may contain stochastic elements.
Examples
Uses a die roll and Laplace’s demon to contrast apparent randomness with outcomes determined by complete physical causes.
What you can do after
Understand how probability can represent incomplete knowledge even when a modeled data-generating process is deterministic.
How it connects
Connects determinism to data-generating processes, subjective probability, probabilistic modeling, and structural causal models.

Also explained in

Compare how 10 books explain determinism →

Related concepts

This explainer was generated by Manning's knowledge graph from the text of Causal AI. The section links point to the parts of the book it draws on.