liveBook · Manning

Incoherence detection

As explained in Inside AI

Incoherence detection is the identification of objects or events that violate expected contextual or relational consistency.

Incoherence detection identifies objects or events that violate expected contextual or relational consistency. It depends on recognizing what belongs together and noticing when something is out of place. section 6.2.2

Recognizing what does not belong

People immediately understand that a car does not belong in a microwave, chairs do not fly, and a kitchen scene is unlikely to contain a hot tub or lawnmower. These judgments rely on connections between objects and their environments, not merely on recognizing pixels. section 6.2.2

Current AI systems struggle with this ability because object recognition does not automatically provide meaning, relationships, or practical expectations. Visual understanding also draws on reasoning and imagination, such as knowing that a plastic banana cannot ripen, peel, or be eaten. section 6.2.2

How Inside AI covers it

How deep it goes
Contrasts human contextual reasoning with AI recognition, but stops short of implementation procedures or algorithms.
Examples
Uses cars in microwaves, flying chairs, unusual kitchen objects, and plastic bananas as examples of violated expectations.
What you can do after
Evaluate why recognizing objects differs from understanding whether their placement or properties make sense.
How it connects
Connects object recognition with visual reasoning, logical reasoning, imagination, and contextual relationships.

Related concepts

This explainer was generated by Manning's knowledge graph from the text of Inside AI. The section links point to the parts of the book it draws on.