liveBook · Manning

Provenance

As explained in Architecting for Autonomy

The documented, traceable history linking a derived artifact or data item to its source information, transformations, movements, and uses.

A legal agent preparing a contract dispute may work from a call recording, a transcript, and an agent-generated summary. Provenance is the traceable history connecting each artifact to its sources, transformations, and use. It helps prevent an interpretation from acquiring the status of verified evidence merely because it appears in a matter file. section 5.1.1 section 5.3.2

Keep the progression explicit: raw input → extracted representation → interpretation → evidential claim → agent-facing context. Each transition produces an artifact with its own uncertainty and permitted use. Where consent, retention, and policy allow, link derived artifacts back to their raw sources. section 5.3.2

Carry enough information forward to assess the artifact at the next decision point:

  • Identify the source, relevant segment, capture context, timestamp, and integrity information. section 5.3.2
  • Record the transformation method, model or tool version, confidence, and lineage. section 5.3.2
  • Distinguish evidential status, permitted purpose, and review requirements from the artifact’s content. section 5.3.2
Listing 5.2 Sample multimodal transformation record
Source reference: CALL-1042-07
Original Transcript: location of transcription is specified here.
Relevant segment: 00:18:42–00:19:17
Capture and integrity: Recorded through approved matter channel; integrity check passed
Extracted representation: Timestamped transcript segment
Transformation method: Speech-to-text model and version
Speaker attribution: Supplier representative
Extraction confidence: 0.71
Interpretation: Possible acknowledgment of repeated delivery delays
Factual proposition: The supplier representative referred to recurring delivery failures during the disputed period
Evidential status: Unverified and disputed
Required corroboration: Review of the recording, confirmation of speaker identity, and comparison with delivery records
Permitted use: Internal issue identification and evidence planning
Prohibited use: Treating the statement as a formal admission or including it in an external legal assertion
Review requirement: Supervising lawyer
Trusted Context status: Research use only until corroborated

The sample transformation record links a call segment to its transcript and interpretation, while recording uncertainty, corroboration requirements, and permitted use. section 5.3.2

Provenance does not prove that a source exists, is accurate, or is suitable as authority. If a source or transformation cannot support the intended use, seek corroboration, qualify the proposition, reduce the agent’s authority, or escalate. section 5.1.1 section 5.3.2

Provenance also applies to governed relationships. A knowledge graph can return relationships with their provenance, version, jurisdiction, effective period, and assertion status. Preserve approval status and ownership as well, and validate relationships before retrieval so an inferred relationship cannot appear approved or a superseded provision governing. section 5.4.1 section 5.8.5

How Architecting for Autonomy covers it

How deep it goes
Specifies transformation metadata, evidence boundaries, and runtime responses, then extends provenance to validation of governed relationships.
Examples
Uses a supplier call, its transcript and interpretation, and a contract knowledge graph to illustrate traceable artifacts and relationships.
What you can do after
Evaluate and understand whether derived evidence supports a proposed use, and identify when to corroborate, qualify, or escalate.
How it connects
Connects lineage with data classification, evidential status, knowledge graphs, and policy enforcement.

Also explained in

Compare how 18 books explain provenance →

Related concepts

This explainer was generated by Manning's knowledge graph from the text of Architecting for Autonomy. The section links point to the parts of the book it draws on.