liveBook · Manning

Simulation

As explained in Machines that Think

Simulation is the computational or formal reproduction of the behavior or operation of a system.

Simulation reproduces a process’s behavior or structure; instantiation realizes the process itself. A computer can simulate a storm without making anything wet, while a calculator performs arithmetic. Whether simulated reasoning counts as reasoning remains contested. section 9.1.4

Functionalism makes performance relevant: what a system does may matter more than what it is made of. But successful imitation alone does not settle whether a system understands or means what it says. Current AI may show reasoning and adaptation while lacking aspects of human cognition, so neither equivalence nor empty imitation follows automatically. section 9.1.4 section 1.5.8 section 9.5.6

Figure 9.3 Same tools, different act. A master copyist may use the same tools and produce a visually similar result, yet intention, authorship, history, and context still shape how we judge the work. The example shows why skilled performance can be real without settling what kind of act the performance belongs to.

A copyist’s visually similar painting illustrates how skilled performance can be real while authorship, intention, and context affect what kind of act it represents. section 9.1.4

How Machines that Think covers it

How deep it goes
Defines simulation against instantiation and uses storms and arithmetic to illustrate the distinction, while leaving reasoning’s status unresolved.
Examples
Contrasts a simulated storm with arithmetic and compares a skilled copyist’s painting with an original.
What you can do after
Evaluate whether a system performs an activity or merely reproduces its structure.
How it connects
Connects simulation to instantiation, functionalism, intentionality, machine understanding, grounding, and semantics.

Also explained in

Compare how 11 books explain simulation →

Related concepts

This explainer was generated by Manning's knowledge graph from the text of Machines that Think. The section links point to the parts of the book it draws on.