An evaluation dataset contains the inputs, examples, and test cases used to assess an AI system and compute evaluation measures. Depending on the system, it may include labeled medical images, questions with retrieved documents and reference answers, or simulated environments for testing agents. section 4.0
The dataset determines which situations the system encounters and which behaviors, risks, and capabilities the evaluation can detect. Missing subgroups can make a system appear fair; missing dangerous edge cases can make it appear safe. A strong metric cannot compensate for data that is unfit for the decision. section 4.0 section 4.7
Testing a medical advice chatbot
A public medical question-answering benchmark may contain clean, expert-written questions, while patients may describe symptoms vaguely or incorrectly. Pilot logs capture more realistic usage but contain sensitive information and may rarely include dangerous cases. Synthetic cases can fill gaps, but their realism must be checked. section 4.1 section 4.7
Sources offer different kinds of evidence and different risks:
- Benchmarks provide standardized baselines for comparison, but may not reflect deployment conditions and can become stale or embed biases. section 4.7
- Operational data reflects actual users and workflows, but privacy constraints, incomplete logs, demographic skews, and rare-event gaps can limit its use. section 4.7
- Synthetic data can support stress testing and expand coverage when real data is scarce, but can oversimplify situations or inherit generator biases. section 4.7
- Other sources include external real-world data and human-generated examples; each source has its own costs and risks. section 4.2
Sampling should match the evaluation goal, with deliberate choices about coverage, representativeness, diversity, and difficulty. Proportional sampling alone may miss rare but high-risk cases. Dataset size also depends on the decision: debugging may need few examples, while comparative, safety, and fairness evaluations require enough data for their conclusions. section 4.3 section 4.1 section 4.7
Before reuse, compare the dataset’s task definition, user intent, and assumptions about good behavior with the intended application. A dataset that rewards long answers, for example, may be unsuitable for clinical triage where brevity, warnings, and escalation matter. Check factual and labeling correctness, including whether judgments remain valid for the current setting and time. section 4.5.1 section 4.5.2
Use the dataset to support a specific evaluation decision, not to stand in for the whole deployment context. Examine coverage and correctness alongside the resulting measures, and avoid treating a fluent response or a benchmark score as proof of safety. section 1.5 section 4.7








































