liveBook · Manning

Chapter 8: The unreasonable effectiveness of engagement

What you will learn in chapter 8 of Hidden Influences

This introduction frames engagement-based recommender systems as socio-technical systems shaped by users, technology, and historical context.

After this chapter you will be able to

What it builds on

Section by section

Introduction

This introduction frames engagement-based recommender systems as socio-technical systems shaped by users, technology, and historical context.

Key terms: socio-technical, engagement-based recommender systems, feedback loop, validation, training data

8.1 The people

This section connects evolved human psychology and fast, automatic thinking to engagement with social media.

Key terms: evolution, reward cycles, habit loops, System 1, System 2, rage-baiting, recommender systems

8.1.1 Group belonging

This section explains how group belonging shapes comparison, identity, conformity, and public shaming, especially on social media.

Key terms: group belonging, cooperation, social comparison theory, sampling bias, engagement, majority illusion, local view, global view, social identity theory, in-group

8.1.2 The search for novelty

This section explains how novelty, low-friction scrolling, and unpredictable rewards can encourage repeated social media use.

Key terms: novelty, infinite scroll, System 1 thinking, System 2 thinking, Skinner box, reward, Schedules of Reinforcement, dopamine, intermittent reinforcement, reward probability

8.2 The technology

This section explains how engagement-based recommender systems’ versatility and interaction with human needs contribute to their influence.

Key terms: engagement data, hidden correlations, recommender systems, communities, group belonging

8.2.1 Communities and like-minded users

This section explains how recommender systems connect and activate communities, shape tastes and language, and can spread both valuable and harmful content.

Key terms: communities, recommender systems, virtual support groups, feedback loop, real self, algorithmic self, socio-technical, community creation, interactions, links

8.2.2 Out-of-Network content

This section explains how Out-of-Network recommendations expand content’s reach and can contribute to context collapse, self-consciousness, and the normalization of extreme content.

Key terms: In-Network, Out-of-Network, engaging, context collapse, loss of the private self, social anxiety, engagements, Out-of-Network recommendations, extreme content, normalizing

8.2.3 Feedback loops and extreme content

This section explains how competition for attention and engagement feedback can encourage increasingly extreme content and normalize harmful material.

Key terms: System 1 thinking, clickbait, FOMO, engagement, Out-of-Network recommendation, feedback loop, extreme content, baseline, arms race, harmful content

8.2.4 Rabbit holing

This section explains how recommendation feedback can gradually lead users from benign interests toward harmful content and communities.

Key terms: rabbit-holing, autoplay, baseline shifts, feedback loop, popular content, Facebook groups’ recommendations, shared membership, content-agnostic, niche, value judgments

8.2.5 The firehose problem: scale and speed

This section explains how rapidly emerging data voids, evasive language, and popularity-driven recommendations can outpace human responses to harmful content.

Key terms: data voids, search term, computer speed, human speed, algospeak, safety guardrails, downranked, popularity, content-agnostic, human supervision

8.3 Society

This section places recommender systems in a social and historical context, arguing that they accelerated existing trends rather than creating all the problems associated with them.

Key terms: recommender systems, polarized, Cold War, liberal democracy, tribalist mentality, free trade, specialize, feedback loop, Fairness Doctrine, partisan cable news

8.4 Summary

Where this is used later

Concepts explained in this chapter

← Chapter 7: Societal impact Chapter 9: Understanding platform incentives →

These guides are generated from the text of Manning books by Manning's knowledge graph and link to the sections they draw on. The full books are available on liveBook and at manning.com.