Trust determines how much room an agent receives to act inside a hard governance ceiling. That room can expand or contract with observed outcomes and the risk of the current task. Reliability on familiar, reversible work does not necessarily justify the same freedom on a new, irreversible task. section 9.1.1
A hard ceiling remains in force regardless of trust: it can prohibit access to resources, cap amounts, or require another authority for certain actions. Progressive trust changes working room within those limits; it does not waive an explicit denial. section 9.1.1 section 9.8
In Argus, a governance facade orders the tool-call path: approval gate, trust decision, policy envelope, and observation. An ASK decision is provisional: the trust check may waive human review at the current scoped level. At SUPERVISED, a medium-risk edit can proceed this way, while a high-risk command still asks and a critical external effect always asks. The outcome is recorded for the next trust decision. section 9.8
Human approval needs evidence, not just a request. The host retains a versioned review packet containing the objective, target, proposed change, evidence reference, and policy version. The callback displays the evidence and returns the approving reviewer’s identifier, or declines. section 9.8
Trust also shapes control placement. A guarded state-changing action sits below higher-trust controls: a pre-check decides whether it may start, a controlled executor limits it, and a post-check queries protected evidence before accepting the result. Keep policies and verifiers outside the agent’s writable state. section 6.5
The governance boundary protects only calls routed through it. The Argus checkpoint governs repository reads and lint actions, but other module calls still bypass the facade; a production build must route every operation with an external effect through the same boundary. section 9.8
Table 9.1 The autonomy spectrum. Five operational levels and a research horizon.
|
Level
|
Name
|
Agent role
|
Human role
|
Example
|
|
0
|
Observe
|
Suggests only
|
Decides and executes
|
Shadow-mode review
|
|
1
|
Assist
|
Reads, analyzes, and proposes
|
Reviews and acts
|
Read-only review assistant
|
|
2
|
Supervised
|
Executes routine actions
|
Approves higher-risk actions
|
Coding agent with approval
|
|
3
|
Autonomous
|
Handles bounded workflows
|
Reviews outcomes
|
Bounded background agent
|
|
4
|
Delegated
|
Operates within an explicit charter
|
Monitors and audits
|
Production agent within charter
|
|
5
|
Self-governing
|
Sets its own objectives
|
Audits periodically
|
Research horizon; not deployed
|
Compare the agent and human roles at each autonomy level; trust changes the room granted within the governing limits. section 9.1.1

















